The Editorial Review Panel Shares Its “Editorial Principles”

[Excerpted from the introduction to a longer document on this subject.]

Over the years, devotees have expressed interest in knowing more about The Bhaktivedanta Book
Trust’s book editing policies and practices, especially in making corrections to Srila Prabhupada’s books
after his physical departure.

To address the devotees’ concerns and to ensure the fidelity of Srila Prabhupada’s published works, on
October 17, 2019, the BBT and the GBC conjointly selected and assembled an independent panel of
devotees qualified by their devotional standing and deep study of Srila Prabhupada’s books. A number
of the panel members are also experienced in editing and editorial processes. This panel is called the
Editorial Review Panel (ERP [previously known as the RRP]).

The ERP’s first order of business was to define the editorial principles they would use to evaluate the
editing the BBT has done, especially since 1977. Their paper, “Editorial Principles,” (ratified by the
Global BBT on July 13, 2021) follows. Aside from a description of the editorial principles themselves,
you will also find the list of ERP members, information on how the editorial principles were formulated,
more about the ERP’s mandate, and what will be done with the ERP’s work.

This paper is intended to be a “living document” – that is, it may be amended whenever the review work
requires that a principle be added or made clearer or expanded upon to encompass examples the
reviewers encounter. Both editing and the reviewing of it are dynamic processes, and inevitably not
everything will fit neatly into one category or another; so we’ve left room for this paper to develop, as
needed. An amendment will be made when it helps the ERP to more closely align with Srila
Prabhupada’s instructions. For this reason, the BBT may approve and publish an occasional revision of
the “Editorial Principles” to keep the ERP’s process transparent.

Your servants
Global BBT

Posted in:

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.